In this emotionally charged ballad, the narrator grapples with feelings of nostalgia and loss following a breakup. The lyrics poignantly reflect on intimate moments shared with a former lover, contrasting these memories with the current reality where another has taken his place. Through rhetorical questioning, the narrator expresses doubt about whether the new partner can match the depth of connection and attention to detail that characterized their past relationship. The recurring theme centers around longing for a return to past intimacy and an implicit hope that his former partner still values what they once had. Ultimately, "Like We Used To" explores themes of love, loss, and the haunting permanence of memories in the aftermath of romantic relationships.
